Parrot AR.Drone 2.0
Dan Bracaglia
After
enthusiastically covering the debut of
Parrot at the Consumer Electronics Show back in 2010, PopSci went on to honor the camera-equipped, remotely-piloted quadrotor with a
Best of What’s New distinction.
And so with that in mind I unboxed the newest iteration--properly named
AR.Drone 2.0--prepared for some degree of disappointment.
Second-generation products, as often as not, tend to correct flaws in
the first generation and marginally refresh or update certain features
(now with HD camera!) without drastically improving or reinventing the
core product or experience. I approached Parrot’s newest drone
accordingly.
This was a misjudgment. That’s not to say the AR.Drone 2.0 is a
completely re-imagined concept--the aerial vehicle itself is essentially
the same--but the latest version has taken several significant
technological strides forward, packing a stronger suite of sensor
technology and improved hardware that make piloting the quadcopter an
order of magnitude more intuitive (and a whole lot of fun).
WHAT’S NEW
Outwardly the AR.Drone 2.0 is still the same quadcopter, bearing a few
minor aesthetic changes. The significant upgrades are all interior. A
new pressure sensor helps keep the AR.Drone 2.0 vertically stable at
altitudes as high as 164 feet (the first-gen drone’s ultrasound sensors
maintained stability only up to about 20 feet). A 3-axis magnetometer
joins the 3-axis gyro and 3-axis accelerometer that were already there,
making it significantly easier to pilot (more on that later). Version
2.0 also received its first built-in, automated maneuvering
function--double-tap the screen of your control device (like its
predecessor, the AR.Drone 2.0 is controlled via a smartphone or tablet
app) and the aircraft executes a midair flip.
And, yes, the drone’s front camera can now shoot in 720p HD at 30
frames per second, which it beams right to the screen of whatever
smartphone or tablet you are using to pilot, giving you a drone’s-eye
view. But it now also records that footage, dumping video and still
images to an on-board USB drive or to the pilot’s control device.
Privacy advocates might have something to say about that, but as a
feature it lends the Parrot AR.Drone 2.0 an added aspect of utility
beyond simple recreation.

Piloting the AR.Drone via iPad: Dan Bracaglia
WHAT’S GOOD
Enhanced Control: As noted above, Parrot’s drones are controlled
via a smartphone or tablet app (we used both an iPad and an iPhone for
this review, with similar good results for each) through an interface
that is in one sense remarkably intuitive and in another mildly
frustrating. The drone mimics the tilt of your device, so to fly it
forward you tilt your smartphone forward, and to fly right or left or
backward or some combination of those, you tilt your smartphone
accordingly. That’s the intuitive part. But when you rotate the drone
(which is done via a touchscreen joypad within the app) to the point
where you and the drone are no longer facing the same direction--let’s
say the drone is facing 90 degrees to your right--all intuition
dissolves immediately. Now, if you tilt your phone forward the drone
travels to your right. If you tilt your phone to the right, the drone
comes back toward you.
Parrot remedied the need for the pilot to be constantly
compensating for the direction the drone is facing via a 3-axis
magnetometer that tells the drone precisely how it is oriented
respective to the control device. With the “Absolute Control” option
switched on in the app’s settings, the drone flies with respect to the
way the device is facing, regardless of which way the drone is facing
(if you tilt your phone to the left, the drone always flies to your left
regardless of whether that’s the drone’s left or not). This drastically
simplifies piloting. Where version 1.0 took a period of getting used
to, a user can get comfortable piloting version 2.0 virtually right out
of the box.
Flight Stability: As you will see at the end of the
accompanying video, there is a brief moment after takeoff during which
the AR.Drone 2.0 appears a little unsteady as its sensors establish a
stable hover. But the new pressure sensor really does seem to
deliver--Parrot claims that the drone can steadily climb to 164 feet and
remain stable in calm conditions, and while we never took it quite that
high (we found that the Wi-Fi link that connects device to drone would
sever before we could get up that high) we did take it up more than a
few dozen feet. Wind gusts have a tendency to upend it a bit, in which
case it can lose some altitude pretty precipitously, but in all cases
the drone re-established a stable hover almost immediately. We only
managed to crash our AR.Drone 2.0 a few times, almost exclusively
indoors while negotiating obstacles and almost always due to pilot
error/bravado.
Software Interface: The piloting software itself hasn’t
undergone a radical transformation in the second iteration--in fact, the
software used to pilot 1.0 doesn’t isn’t supported anymore, so if you
own a AR.Drone version 1.0, you now use the new 2.0 software to pilot
both versions. But there are some handy features embedded in the app
that make it easy to share your videos straight to YouTube (you can
actually log into Google/YouTube/Picasa through the app and dump your
flight videos or pics right to your media channels) or to connect with
other pilots through the AR.Drone Academy, Parrot's online community for
AR.Drone pilots where they can easily swap photos and videos, share
flight data to unlock achievements, and find other pilots flying nearby.
The Academy aspect is also useful for those looking to explore the
community for software hacks developed through AR.Drone's open API.
WHAT’S BAD
Battery Life: If there’s an aspect of the refreshed Parrot
AR.Drone that we found unsatisfactory, it's the rechargeable lithium
polymer battery. We can't dock too many points here. The AR.Drone 2.0
stays aloft as long as comparable RC aircraft, and we’re sensitive to
battery cost and power density issues and the challenges inherent in
balancing power and weight in any aircraft of any size. It's simply
somewhat annoying that AR.Drone’s battery takes between an hour and an
hour-and-a-half to fully charge, and from that we averaged 15-25 minutes
of continuous flight. That’s not great, especially for a recreational
machine best enjoyed outdoors away from the wall socket (though we did
have a blast piloting ours through PopSci’s Manhattan cubicle farm).
Parrot does offer extra batteries for $39.99 online. If you want to fly
for any extended period of time, we recommend you suck it up and buy
one. At least one.
No New AR Games (Yet): Part of the draw to the original
AR.Drone was that it wasn’t just a remote control aircraft, but a new
kind of hybrid physical/virtual gaming device. Several augmented reality
games were designed, most of which were multiplayer/multi-air combat or
racing games, in which AR overlays allowed users to shoot virtual
missiles at each other or some such. AR.Drone 2.0 comes with no new
games, the existing 1.0 games aren’t really optimized for the 2.0
(though they will be, we’re told), and there’s no word yet on whether or
when Parrot will make additional games for version 2.0. But should you
be so inclined, you can always design your own; as noted above,
AR.Drone’s API is open and developers are encouraged to hack away.
THE PRICE
The AR.Drone 2.0 is available now and retails for $299.99. You can order online from
Parrot directly, but they also can be found at Brookstone and at Barnes and Noble. Extra batteries retail from Parrot for $39.99.
THE VERDICT
Like its predecessor, the AR.Drone 2.0 is a really fun machine. Unlike
its predecessor, version 2.0 requires almost no getting used to--it’s
intuitively simple to fly right out of the box. The enhanced
controllability enabled by the magnetometer and the “Absolute Control”
feature make piloting this drone easy and extremely enjoyable. Children
can fly it (with adult supervision, of course). Adults can fly it, and
will enjoy it as much as children. The price, while perhaps not exactly
right for every budget, is competitive in the context of higher-end
model helicopters or airplanes, and where quadrotors are concerned it
really doesn’t have any competition in its weight class. You can cobble
together your own quadcopter from various DIY kits and the like, but
you’re still going to end up paying dearly for the privilege. For a
quality out-of-the-box technology at an accessible price point, Parrot
is really carving out a nice little niche in the recreational drone
space.
That being said, with battery life being so underwhelming it’s
difficult to promise hours of free-flying fun--perhaps it’s more
accurate to promise many 20-minute chunks of piloting glee. But Parrot
got so many things right with this aircraft. It really is a significant
improvement over the first-generation AR.Drone--which wasn’t a bad drone
by any stretch. Batteries get better, and sensors and electronics get
cheaper, smaller, and more efficient. I personally wouldn’t let the
short battery life discourage me from taking the current AR.Drone 2.0
home from the store, but the trajectory of the product line thus far
suggests to me that we’re only starting to scratch the surface of what
these drones can do. I’m really more excited to see what improvements
Parrot is able to pack into version 3.0.